[Par-reg.w] For Parshat Re'eh - shiur

[Menachem Leibtag]

*************************************************************
        THE TANACH STUDY CENTER [http://www.tanach.org]
In Memory of Rabbi Abraham Leibtag
Shiurim in Chumash & Navi by Menachem Leibtag
*************************************************************

PARSHAT RE'AY

To our surprise, the city of Jerusalem (by that name) is never mentioned in
Chumash.  However, the underlying concept of that eternal city does emerge
as a major theme in Parshat Re’ay.
In the following shiur, we uncover the 'foundations of the city of
Jerusalem' in our study of the Torah's repeated use of the phrase:
"ha'makom asher yivchar Hashem" [lit. the site that God will choose], and
its thematic significance within the laws of Sefer Devarim.

INTRODUCTION
When we speak of Jerusalem, we usually relate to either one of its two
aspects:
a) its geographic location
b) its function as the national center of the Jewish Nation.

Even though Chumash never informs us in regard to its precise location, its
function as a 'national center' for the Jewish Nation unfolds as a primary
theme in Sefer Devarim.
To understand how and why, we must begin our shiur by returning to our
analysis of the CHUKIM & MISHPATIM section of the main speech of Sefer
Devarim.

Recall from our introductory shiur how Sefer Devarim includes a lengthy
speech delivered by Moshe Rabeinu to Bnei Yisrael (chaps. 5-26) where he
reviews the laws that Bnei Yisrael must keep when they enter the land.
That speech divides neatly into two distinct sections:
I - "ha'MITZVA" (6:4 - 11:31)
II- "ha'CHUKIM v'ha'MISHPATIM (12:1 - 26:19)

The MITZVAH section, we explained, focused on the proper attitude towards
God - such as the mitzvah of "ahavat Hashem" (see 6:5,10:12,11:22), while
the CHUKIM & MISHPATIM section focused on the actual mitzvot that Bnei
Yisrael must keep when setting up their nation in the Land - laws that will
help transform them into a "goy kadosh" [a holy nation].  (See Shmot 19:5-6
& Devarim 5:1-2 & 26:16-19.)
These 'practical laws' begin in Parshat Re'ay (see 12:1) and continue all
the way until the laws of "bikurim" in Parshat Ki-tavo (see 26:1-15).  As
this section is the Torah's largest corpus of laws, not only is its content
important, but even more so, its manner of presentation, and especially its
first topic.
    We begin our shiur by showing how (and why) the concept of "ha''makom
asher yivchar Hashem" emerges as it opening topic.

HA'MAKOM ASHER YIVCHAR HASHEM
Let's read the opening psukim of the CHUKIM & MISHPATIM section, noting the
progression of topic:

[introductory pasuk]
"THESE are the 'chukim & mishpatim' which you must observe in the LAND
WHICH HASHEM IS GIVING YOU... :

[first law - to rid the land of idol worship]
* You must totally destroy all the sites where the nations worshiped their
idols... on the high hills and mountains... you must ERADICATE THEIR NAMES
from this place.

[second law - where to worship your God]
* DO NOT WORSHIP YOUR GOD IN THIS MANNER (in multiple places of worship/
read carefully!).
* Rather, at the SITE WHICH GOD WILL CHOOSE - HA'MAKOM ASHER YIVCHAR HASHEM
- amongst all your tribes, - LASUM ET SHMO SHAM; -
      "l'shichno ti'DRSHU u'ba'ta shama"

[misc. laws re: this 'place' to worship God]
  * THERE you must bring all of your offerings and tithes etc. Eat and
rejoice there in front of your Lord...
* ... After you cross the Jordan and enter the Land and find rest from your
enemies and enjoy security, then - HA'MAKOM ASHER YIVCHAR HASHEM L'SHAKEYN
SHMO SHAM - bring THERE everything I command...
* Be careful not to offer your sacrifices anywhere that you want, rather at
HA'MAKOM ASHER YIVCHAR HASHEM, only THERE may you bring your offerings...
(see 12:1-14)

    As you review these psukim, note how the opening commandment [to
destroy all places of idol worship] serves as a 'pre-requisite' for the
primary commandment that follows -i.e. to establish a central 'SITE IN
WHICH GOD'S NAME WILL DWELL'.
Note as well how the Hebrew word "shem" [name/reputation] also ties both of
these topics together.  First Am Yisrael must eradicate the 'names of the
other gods' from the land; afterward they must establish instead a place
for 'His Name' to dwell.
    In relation to the framework of the main speech, this opening
commandment is quite appropriate, for Bnei Yisrael are about to enter and
conquer the Promised Land in order to establish God's special nation.  This
first obligation - to transform Eretz Canaan from a place of idol worship
into a land in which God's Name (i.e. His reputation) becomes known - is
accomplished by first ridding the land from 'the names of OTHER gods'
(12:2-3), and then by establishing a national religious center – which
Sefer Devarim refers to as "ha'MAKOM asher yichar Hashem l'shakein SHMO
sham".
A RECURRING THEME
As you continue your study of Parshat Re'ay, note how often the phrase -
HAMAKOM ASHER YIVCHAR HASHEM is repeated.  Not only several times in the
opening "parshia" (i.e. chapter 12),  but also some twenty times throughout
the entire CHUKIM & MISHPATIM section of the main speech (chapters 12-26)!
As illustrated in the following table, not only is it the FIRST topic of
this section, it also develops as a recurring theme.
The table below summarizes each mention of the phrase "ha'makom asher
yivchar Hashem" together with its related topic:

PEREK/:pasuk TOPIC
=========== =====
12:5,11,14,18,21,26  The place to bring all "korbanot"
14:23,24,25 The place to eat "maaser sheni" [tithes]
15:20 The place to eat the 'first-born' animal
16:2,6,7,11,15,16  The site for "aliya l'regel" on the holidays
17:8,10 The seat of the Supreme Court
18:6 The service of the Leviim
26:2 The place to bring one's "bikurim" [first fruits]

A NATIONAL CENTER
A quick glance at this table immediately shows that the purpose of this
site is not only to offer 'korbanot'; rather it emerges as a National
Religious Center.  These various mitzvot (as summarized in the above table)
facilitate the establishment of this center.  Note as well how often every
person must visit this site!
First and foremost, every individual is obligated to make a pilgrimage to
the site on the three agricultural holidays ("aliyah l'regel" / see chapter
16), and whenever he offers a "korban" (be it "n'dava" [voluntary] or
"chovah" [obligatory]).
The farmer must bring there not only his first fruits ("bikurim"), but also
10% of his harvest to eat and share at this site ("maaser sheni").
Likewise, the shepherd must bring not only the first born animals
("bchor"), but also 10% of his entire flock ("maaser b'heyma")!
Furthermore, the Supreme Court for all judicial and halachik judgment is to
be located at this site.
Should the people of Israel follow these numerous laws concerning HAMAKOM
ASHER YIVCHAR HASHEM - this site would greatly facilitate the development
of Am Yisrael as God's special nation.  The establishment of this center,
and the obligation of every individual to frequent this site, ensures the
unity of the people and of the religion.
[Without such a center, within several generations it would be more likely
that we would find twelve different religions rather than twelve tribes.]

This site would also become a center justice, judgment, Torah education,
and culture - enhancing the spirituality not only of the nation, but also
of each individual who would come to viist.

MAASER SHENI
To support this point, let's take a closer look at the mitzvah of "maaser
sheni", as described in chapter 14:
"You shall set aside every year a tenth of the yield of your field. And you
should eat this tithe in the presence of your Lord "baMakom asher yivchar
Hashem l'shakeyn shmo sham"... IN ORDER THAT YOU LEARN TO FEAR GOD
forever..." (14:22)

In other words, each farmer must separate a ten percent tithe of his
produce, and then take that produce [or its value] and eat it in Jerusalem
- and the purpose of this mitzvah is - 'in order that you learn to fear
God'!
But why should simply 'eating food' at this site cause one to fear God?  To
understand why, we must conjecture as to how this site was to develop.
Even though it is not explicitly stated, it is implicit that the Bet
Ha'Mikdash [Temple] was to become the focal point of this national center -
for the simple reason that Devarim commands us to bring all of our
"korbanot" there. [These are obviously the same korbanot as described in
Sefer Vayikra.]
However, "maaser sheni" itself is produce, and not an animal offering (i.e.
it doesn't require a mizbayach).  Nevertheless; the Torah demands that we
eat this "maser" at this site.  This implies that there must be an
additional area surrounding the Mikdash where this "maser" can be eaten.
According to the Halacha, this additional area is defined by the walls of
the CITY that surrounds the Bet HaMikdash - and carries the same halachic
status as the area within the camp of Israel in the desert, where "kodshim
kalim" could be eatern/ i.e. the meat of the "korban shlamim".
But when one eats this "maser" within the walls of this city, other people
will be there as well.  Let's review who else should be in this special
city on a daily basis.   First of all, the Torah designates 'civil
servants' who are to officiate and administer the Bet Ha'Mikdash - i.e. the
"kohanim" and "leviim" - whose entire lives are dedicated to the service of
God. There will also be the judges and scholars of the supreme court
system, populating this 'holy city' surrounding the Temple, infusing it
with an atmosphere of "kedusha" (sanctity).
Therefore, the experience of eating "maaser sheni" in this 'holy' city,
mingling there with the kohanim, leviim, and Torah scholars, while sharing
one's food together with family and the needy (see 14:25-27), would create
an environment that enhances one's "yirat shamayim" - the fear of God.

Note how Chizkuni's interpretation of the pasuk re: "maser sheni" reflects
this same idea:
"...when you will go up [to this site] to eat your maser sheni, you will
see the priests officiating and the levites singing... and the Sanhedrin
sitting in judgment and teaching laws..., and thus learn [from them] how to
fear your God."  (14:23, see also Seforno)

A PROOF FROM HAKHEL
This obligation to frequent HAMAKOM ASHER YIVCHAR HASHEM culminates every
seven years with the "Hakhel" ceremony, where the entire nation - including
the women and children - gather to hear the Torah at this very same site.
Here, once again, we find "yirat Hashem" - the fear of God - as the primary
purpose:
"... every seventh year... when all Israel gathers before Hashem "ba'Makom
asher yivchar", you shall read this Torah (Sefer Dvarim) in the presence of
all Israel. Gather ("hakhel") the people, men, women and children and the
strangers, that they may hear and so learn TO FEAR THE LORD and to
observe... Their children too ... shall hear and learn TO FEAR GOD as long
as they live on the Land..." (see Devarim 31:10-13)

Not only to we find once again the site "hamakom asher yivchar Hashem", we
also find the purpose of this gathering to instill the fear of God in those
who gather.  As you review the above psukim, note as well the similarities
to Ma'amad Har Sinai.  This beautifully supports Ramban's interpretation
that the underlying purpose of the Mikdash was to perpetuate the Sinai
experience (see Ramban on Shmot 25:1 /and TSC shiur on Parshat Terumah).

To conclude our discussion of the 'function' of this site ["hamakom asher
yivchar..."], we return to Torah's special use of the word "makom" in a
very similar context in Sefer Breishit.

THE SITE / THE TEMPLE / AND JERUSALEM
Review the story of Yaakov's dream at the beginning of Parshat Va'yetze
(i.e. Breishit 28:10-22), noting not only the word ha'makom" (five times)
but also its theme.  At the conclusion of this episode, Yaakov vows that
upon his return to this site ["ha'makom"], he will establish a Bet Elokim -
a House for God.  Here, we already find a thematic connection between the
word "ha'makom" and the Mikdash.
Similarly, in the story of the "akeyda" (see Breishit chapter 22)` the
Torah uses the word "makom" to describe that site.  [See 22:2,3,4,9,14.]
Recall as well how Avraham Avinu names this "makom" - "Hashem yireh" (see
22:14), a site that Chazal later identify as the very same mountain where
the Bet Ha'Mikdash was built in Yerushalayim.  In fact, in Divrei ha'yamim
we are informed that Shlomo ha'melech built the Bet ha'Mikdah on Har
ha'Moriah, the site of the "akeyda" (see II D.H. 3:1-3).

Even though it is not clear where Yaakov's dream took place, the Torah's
use of the word "makom" in both stories, and their common theme certainly
support Chazal's conclusion that both events happened at the same site (see
Rashi 28:11), which later became the Bet ha'Mikdash in Yerushalayim.

HOLY GROUND OR HOLY PURPOSE
Our analysis thus far demonstrates how the Torah puts more emphasis on the
'function', than the location, of this site.  In fact, the Torah appears to
be rather evasive in regard to where this site is actually to be located
(see below).
However, this very point may be very fundamental towards our understanding
of Jerusalem.  The site is special because of its function - to serve as a
national center, to promote the reputation of God's Name ["shem Hashem"]
among all mankind.
This emphasis is important, for man is very vulnerable towards focusing on
the holiness of a site rather than the holiness of its purpose.  [Sort of
like dovening TO the "kotel" instead dovening AT the "kotel", or saying
tehillim TO "kivrei tzadikim" instead of AT "kivrei tzadikim".]
For this reason, most all of the later prophets rebuke the people of Israel
for misunderstanding the Temple in this manner.  Take for example Yirmiyahu
chapter 7 (in case you are not familiar, read 7:1-28, see also the first
chapter of Yeshayahu).  This rebuke does not imply that there is no value
to holy sites.  Precisely the opposite, the physical location is important
for it provides a vehicle to promote its purpose.  Yet, one must always be
careful not to allow the holiness of the site to override the holiness of
its purpose.
[For a nice perspective on the balance between these two ideas, see
Tehillim 51.  Note how first David ha'melech first explains how "korbanot"
or futile, for God seeks man's proper behavior; nonetheless, that chapter
concludes with David's prayer that Jerusalem be built, and that God should
accept our offerings. As this is a rather 'touchy topic', I'd rather you
base your conclusions of David ha'Melech's explanation, rather than my own.]

JERUSALEM / SEEK AND FIND
As we have shown, Sefer Devarim never specifies the precise geographic
location of where this site is to be, i.e. where the permanent Bet
HaMikdash is to be constructed.  Instead, the site is consistently referred
to as "the one which God will choose" ("HaMakom asher yivchar Hashem").
However, in Parshat Reay we do find a very obscure hint regarding how we
are to find this site:  "l'shichno ti'drshu, u'bata shama" - (see 12:5)
God will only show us the site if WE look for it. This 'hide and seek' type
relationship is reflective of every Divine encounter.  To find God, man
must SEARCH for Him.  According to these psukim in Parshat Re’ay, this
principle applies to the nation in same manner as it applies to the
individual.  [As we say in the daily Ashrei: "karov Hashem l'chol kor'av" -
God is close to those who call out to Him.]
When Am Yisrael as a nation, begins a serious search for God, then God will
show them the proper location to build the Mikdash.
The generation of Yehoshua, despite their military conquests, did not
succeed in establishing the permanent Mikdash (after conquering the Land).
Instead, they erected the temporary Mishkan in Shilo.  There it remained,
quite neglected, during the entire time period of the Judges.  After the
city of Shilo was destroyed by the Phlishtim (during the time of Eli / see
Shmuel chapters 4-6), both the Mishkan and the "aron" wandered from site to
site.  It was only during the time period of David ha’melech that Bnei
Yisrael actively aspired to build the Mikdash.
For example, when David became king over all of Israel (see II Shmuel
5:1-9), his first act was to conquer the city of Jerusalem.  His next
project was to gather the nation in order to bring the "aron" (the holy
ark) to his new capital city (see II Shmuel chapter 6).  Note how Divrei
ha'yamim describes how David explained his plan (and the reason) to the
nation:
"David said to the entire congregation of Israel: If you approve, and this
is from God (the events of David's rise to power), let us go forward and
invite all our brethren in the land of Israel, together with the KOHANIM
and LEVIIM and gather together, IN ORDER TO BRING BACK to us God's HOLY ARK
- 'ki lo DRASH'NU'HU b'ymei Shaul' - for during the time of Shaul WE DID
NOT SEEK IT"  (I Divrei Hayamim 13:2-3)
[Note the use of the shoresh "d.r.sh." here and in Devarim 12:5]

David Ha'melech notes how the "aron" had been neglected during the
generation of Shaul at the national level.  In contrast to Shaul,  David
ha'melech considered bringing the "aron" to Yerushalayim as his highest
national priority.
After the "aron" finally arrived in Jerusalem, the next step in David's
master plan was to build a permanent house for the "aron", i.e. the Bet
Ha'Mikdash in Yerushalayim:
"When the King was settled in his palace and God has granted him safety
from his enemies [he'niach lo m'kol oyvav m'saviv], the King said to Natan
the prophet:  Here I am dwelling in a HOUSE of cedar wood, while the 'aron'
is dwelling only in a TENT!"   (see II Shmuel 7:1-2)
[Note again the textual parallel to Devarim 12:10-11]

Even though God informed David that Am Yisrael would have to wait another
generation before the Temple could be built (in the next generation by his
son Shlomo, see II Shmuel chapter 7), its precise site was already
designated in David's own lifetime (see I Divrei Ha'yamim 22:1).  In fact,
David ha'melech himself prepared all the necessary building materials (see
the remainder of that chapter).
If you read the above sources carefully, you'll see that the underlying
reason for God's decision to delay its construction for one more generation
stemmed from the need to wait until its 'function' - to make a Name for God
- could be properly fulfilled.

JERUSALEM TODAY
As we have seen in our study, according to the guidelines of Sefer Devarim
- 'Jerusalem' is destined to become more than just the city that houses the
Temple. Ideally, Jerusalem should become the National Cultural and
Religious Center of the Jewish people, whose purpose will be to 'make a
Name' for God.  This aspiration is found in the prophecies of most all of
the later prophets.  For example:
"For Jerusalem will be called the city of Truth ("ir ha'emet"), and the
mountain of the Lord of Hosts -"har ha'Kodesh" (see Zecharya 8:3).

"For out of Zion will come forth Torah and the word of the Lord from
Jerusalem" (see Isaiah 2:3).

Today, be it for halachic, technical, or political reasons, we are not yet
able to rebuild the Bet HaMikdash.  Until the proper time comes, this
aspiration remains our national dream and an everlasting prayer.
Nonetheless, to rebuild the city of Jerusalem as our National Center - a
city of Truth, Justice, and Sanctity - is not only permitted, it is our
duty.  In our own generation, God has opened for us a window of
opportunity.  The achievement of this goal remains our national
responsibility.

shabbat shalom,
menachem
================================
FOR FURTHER IYUN
A. THE CHAGIM IN RE'AY
    Even though the chagim have already been presented in Parshiot
Mishpatim, Emor, and Pinchas, they are repeated again in Devarim chap 16.
Read this chapter carefully.
1. What laws are added which we did not already learn from the earlier
sources?
2. What would you say is the primary topic of this perek? (which key phrase
repeats itself many times?)
3. Attempt to explain this perek as an expansion of Shmot 23:14 17!
4. How does all this relate to the above shiur?
5. Why aren't Rosh Hashana and Yom Kippur mentioned in this parshia?

B. "LO TA'ASUN KEYN L'HASHEM ELOKEICHEM" (12:4)
In the above shiur, we explained that this pasuk implies that we are
commanded not to worship God in multiple places of worship. This is "pshat"
of the pasuk based on 12:2 and 12:5, For just as they worshiped their gods
on the high places and under mighty trees etc. (12:2)  you should not,
rather - only in the place which God chooses ("ha'makom...). That is, at
ONE place and not at many places.
Note the two explanations given by Rashi. The first follows this reading
according to "pshat". The second is a Midrash Halacha.
Do these two pirushim contradict each other, or can they both be correct?
Use your answer to explain the nature of Midrashei Halacha.

C. MIKRA BIKURIM - THE FINALE
Note the final mitzvot of the chukim & mishpatim are Mikra Bikurim and
vidduy maaser (perek 26), again focusing on HA'MAKOM ASHER YIVCHAR HASHEM -
(note 27:1 also).
1. Does this parsha belong in Parshat Ki-tavo, or do you think that
it would be more fitting to Parshat Reay? Relate to the parsha of maaser
sheni (14:22-29)!  Why do think it was chosen to conclude the main speech?
Relate your answer to the purpose of this speech, and the content of "mikra
bikurim" and to Breishit perek 15.

D. Even though Sefer Breishit does not mention Jerusalem by name, it does
mention the city of 'Shalem' (see 14:18) in relation to Malki Tzedek (note
the significance of his name) and Mount Moriah (see 22:2,14), the site of
the Akeyda', as Hashem YIREH.  Together YIREH -SHALEM, may allude to the
final name of this city - YERU-SHALAYIM.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mail.atlchai.org/pipermail/par-reg.w/attachments/20180809/bd1df338/attachment-0001.html>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: reay1.doc
Type: application/msword
Size: 85934 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://mail.atlchai.org/pipermail/par-reg.w/attachments/20180809/bd1df338/attachment-0001.doc>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: reay1.pdf
Type: application/pdf
Size: 48689 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://mail.atlchai.org/pipermail/par-reg.w/attachments/20180809/bd1df338/attachment-0001.pdf>